So Notre Dame
fires Ty Willingham and hopes to hire
Urban Meyer from Utah. It'll probably happen.
On Sports Radio, especially the Mike and the Mad Dog Show, they're saying Notre Dame "can't compete...they can't get the recruits...the standards are too high..." It's all garbage.
Over the last 5 years here are some of the rankings according to Phil Steele (whose magazine is the best)
1999
1. Texas
4. Ohio St
6. Michigan
7. Notre Dame
2000
1. Florida
4. Penn St
5. Texas
6. Notre Dame
2001
1. FSU
4. LSU
5. Notre Dame
6. Miami
2002
1. FSU
4. Tennessee
5. Notre Dame
6. Miami
8. Oklahoma
2003
1. USC
2. Florida
3. Notre Dame
4. Michigan
5. Tennesse
6. Miami, FL.
Sorry, I don't think recruits are the problem. Coaching is obviously the problem.
Brady Quinn was the highest ranked QB in the midwest when he went to Notre Dame.
Julius Jones, who looks to have a tremendous future in the NFL, split time.
David Givens never saw the ball, yet on the New England Patriots he's their goto Red Zone WR.
Randy Moss signed with Notre Dame!
The standards may be higher, slightly, but in reality it's the poor coaching, and the tough early scheduling.
Another thing, is ND gets in on players so early in their high school years that there's no great potential for them to get better. So many players, like a Ron Powlus, max out by their Senior year, at which time they have already signed with Notre Dame. The kids with the potential to be great often become great, as opposed to the high school phenom. This always happens with Notre Dame. Their guys are physically dominant before they get to college, and other guys catch up.
A great example is Joey Galloway of Ohio State, who was a skinny kid that wanted to play for ND. They did not think he was good enough. He went on to become, for a time, the fastest player in the NFL, and probably the strongest guy his size. ND does not recruit potential, they recruit stars. I can name so many guys that went to school there only to become average players.
The standards may be higher, but that does not mean guys like Chad Henne, Michael Doss, Antoine Winfield, Dwayne Jarrett, and others can't play there. They can! They have better grades and test scores than Ricky Watters and Jerome Bettis. And just like in the bigtime colleges, at the prep schools they help these kids pass their classes with flying colors. In fact, I recall New Jersey soccer powerhouse St. Benedicts Prep used to have the honor system wherein the teachers would leave the classroom so the students could take tests. Kids I knew on SBP told me flat out they all cheated, and were all in classes together.
Also, Notre Dame is on national television every week. They have their own network (which is what this is all about). That's a serious advantage. Other teams have to be good to be on the tube week in, week out.
So for all the garbage about Willingham and Bob Davie only getting three years, or that ND does not get the players because of the standards, it's just that: GARBAGE.
Get yourselves a good coach and national dominance will not be far behind.
Btw, Michigan, you should've fired Lloyd Carr last year and hired Meyer before ND.